Glossary

Apollonius of Tyana

"Apollonius of Tyana in Cappadocia (Asia Minor) was a Neophyagorean sage: he followed the teachings of the philosopher Pythagoras (born ca. 521 B.C.E.). Apollonius was born about the same time as Jesus and survived until near the end of the first century C.E. Like Jesus, Apollonius was a wandering sage, offering his advice here and there, sometimes without invitation. He was a vegetarian, wore a linen garment, did not bathe, and frequently fasted. He practiced exorcism, cured the sick, and forecast the future. Christian folk in the third century regarded him as a direct competitor of Jesus."
     - Robert W. Funk, Roy W. Hoover, and the Jesus Seminar, The Five Gospels

"The preserved Life of Apollonius was written by one Flavius Philostratus at the behest of the empress Julia Domna in the early years of the third century and was completed only after her death in 217."
"...The Life of Apollonius presents a literary problem much like that of the gospels. It also resembles them in literary form - after praise of the hero's family and legends about his birth, his childhood is almost wholly passed over and his adult life is presented in a series of anecdotes connected merely by a geographic frame (references to his traveling and the places where this or that happened); the narrative becomes more coherent towards the end of the life with trial, escape, and later adventures, only to blur again when it comes to the death and subsequent appearances. These similarities add weight to another: like the gospels the Life is in part an apologetic work, written not only to glorify its hero, but also to defend him against the charge of practicing magic."
     - Morton Smith, Jesus the Magician: Charlatan or Son of God? (1978) pp. 113, 114

"...The question of whether Philostratus had access to a firsthand source as he claimed (i.e., the diary of Damis, a disciple of Apollonius) or whether Philostratus simply created a good deal of the material himself is still debated by scholars."
"...In the ecumenical and eclectic climate of the circle of Julia Domna [the Empress who was the wife of Septimius Severus who reigned from AD 193-211], Philostratus possibly borrowed some miracle stories from the Gospels to help him flesh out his portrait of Apollonius as a great philosopher and miracle-worker."
     - John P. Meier, A Marginal Jew - Rethinking the Historical Jesus, Vol. 2.

According to Philostratus, "Apollonius of Tyana was born of a well-to-do Greek family in the south-central Anatolian town of which his name preserves the memory. His parents sent him for higher education to the Greek city of Tarsus on the south coast about the same time as the Jewish parents of Paul, in Tarsus, sent their boy to Jerusalem for his education. Both boys came down with incurable religiosity: Paul first became a Pharisee and then was converted to Christianity; Apollonius became a Pythagorean and after some years set out for Babylon where he studies with the magi, and then for India to find the Brahmans and learn their teachings. He come back claiming to have done so, formed a circle of disciples, and lived with them as an itinerant philosopher, holy man, and miracle worker, going from temple to temple along the coasts of northern Syria, Anatolia, and Greece, where Paul, shortly before, had gone from synagogue to synagogue. From Greece, in the last years of Nero, Apollonius went to Rome (where Paul had already been executed). A brush with the police may have persuaded him to push on to Spain where one of the Roman governors was plotting a revolt. After the revolt and Nero's suicide in 68 he returned to Sicily and Greece, then visited Alexandria where in 69 he is said have been consulted by Vespasian at the beginning of his revolt. Vespasian went to Rome, Apollonius to the 'naked sages' in upper Egypt, a community of ascetics with pretensions to supernatural powers. Thence he returned to the eastern Mediterranean where he continued his itinerant life until 93 when he went to Rome to face charges of magic and sedition; he was accused of having sacrificed a Greek boy to divine from his entrails the fate of a conspiracy to kill the emperor Domitian. He reportedly vanished from the courtroom in Rome, returned to Greece, and continued his life there and in Asia Minor undisturbed until his death - some said, his ascent to heaven - shortly after Domitian's assassination in 96. He is also said to have appeared after his ascension or death to a young man who did not believe his teachings."
"The historical similarities between Apollonius and Jesus are clear: both were itinerant miracle workers and preachers, rejected at first by their townspeople and brothers, though the latter eventually became more favorable. An inner circle of devoted disciples accompanied each. Both were credited with prophesies, exorcisms, cures, and an occasional raising of the dead. As preachers both made severe moral demands on their hearers. Both affected epigrammatic utterances and oracular style; they taught as if with authority and came into conflict with the established clergy of the temples they visited and tried to reform. Both were charged with sedition and magic but tried primarily for sedition."
     - Morton Smith, Jesus the Magician: Charlatan or Son of God? (1978) pp. 111-113

Cherubim

The Throne Bearers of Yahweh
Cherubim: "Angelic beings or symbolic representations thereof, mentioned frequently in the Old Testament and once in the New Testament."
     - J.P. Arendzen, "Cheribim", Catholic Encyclopedia

"The LORD reigns, let the nations tremble; he sits enthroned between the cherubim, let the earth shake."
     - Psalm 99:1

"The word cherub (cherubim is the Hebrew masculine plural) is a word borrowed from the Assyrian kirubu, from karãbu, 'to be near', hence it means near ones, familiars, personal servants, bodyguards, courtiers. It was commonly used of those heavenly spirits, who closely surrounded the Majesty of God and paid Him intimate service. Hence it came to mean as much as 'Angelic Spirit'. (The change from K of Karãbu, to K of Kirub is nothing unusual in Assyrian. The word has been brought into connection with the Egyptian Xefer by metathesis from Xeref=K-r-bh.) A similar metathesis and play upon sound undoubtedly exists between Kerub and Rakab, 'to ride', and Merkeba, 'chariot'....The word ought to be pronounced in English qerub and querubim, and not with a soft ch. "
"Cherub and Cherubim are most frequently referred to in the Bible to designate sculptured, engraved, and embroidered figures used in the furniture and ornamentation of the Jewish Sanctuary."
"In Egyptian art, figures with a human face and two outstretched wings attached to the arms are exceedingly common. In Assyrian art, also, winged human figures on either side of a palm tree are very often used in decoration. They are sometimes hawk-headed, but more usually possess men's faces. However, even the Jews at the time of Christ had completely forgotten the appearance of the Temple cherubim. Josephus (Antiq., VIII, 3) says that no one knows or even can guess what form they had. The very fact, however, that the Bible nowhere gives a word of explanation, but always presupposes them well-known, makes us believe that they were among the most common figures of contemporary art. "
"As Jehovah was surrounded by figures of cherubim in His Sanctuary on earth, so He is, according to Scripture, surrounded in reality by cherubim in His Court above. The function ascribed to these heavenly servants of God's Majesty is that of throne-bearers, or 'carriers', of His Divine Majesty."
     - J.P. Arendzen, "Cheribim", Catholic Encyclopedia

"He [Yahweh] rode upon a cherub and flew upon the wings of the wind."
     - Psalm 18:10

"The idea of cherubim as the chariot of God seems indicated in I Paralip. 18, where David gives gold for the Temple cherubim, who are described as 'the Chariot', not, probably, because they had the outward shape of a vehicle, but because the Temple cherubim symbolized the swift-winged living thrones upon which the Almighty journeys through the heavens."
     - J.P. Arendzen, "Cheribim", Catholic Encyclopedia

The Imagery of the Cherubim
"...The cherubim are the living chariots or carriers of God when appearing to men, in winged human form with the faces of lion, ox, man and eagle. They never come close to men."
     - Jim A. Cornwell, "The Mystery of Ezekiel's and John's Vision OT and NT - Cherubim " (from The Alpha and the Omega [1995])

"A superbly carved ivory plaque from Megiddo gives a rare glimpse of the Canaanite royal court. It shows the king, seated on a throne supported by sphinxes, receiving a victory procession."
     - Bible Lands

In the Bible Lands Museum is an "extremely rare and exquisite ivory carved in openwork technique; that is, in places the ivory is cut all the way through. This artifact is about 5.5 inches high and slightly less than 4 inches wide." Cherub
"Clearly, it is a composite figure posed in a garden of palms, which are partially visible between the figure's head and wing; this calls to mind the verse from Ezekiel where the prophet describes his visionary Temple as having cherubim and palm trees carved on the wall (Ezekiel 41:20).
"Our ivory effectively combines the four elements mentioned above - a human face, the wings of an eagle, the forepart of a lion and the hind-part of an ox, although most of the hind legs are missing."

"This ivory plaque can be dated to about the late ninth century B.C.E. The Phoenician style, incorporating Egyptian elements, is well known. Although the provenance of the piece is uncertain, I strongly suspect it was once part of the famous ivory hoard excavated by a French expedition in 1928 at the site of Arslan Tash, about 20 miles east of the upper Euphrates in modern-day Syria. The Arslan Tash ivories were inlaid in the wooden frames of beds (cf. Amos 6:4)."
"If so, it may once have adorned the palace of Hazael, king of Aram-Damascus (848-805 B.C.E.), who was anointed king by the prophet Elijah (1 Kings 19:15). Among the ivories from Arslan Tash was a piece of ivory veneer bearing the name Hazael. Arslan Tash is the ancient site of Hadatu. Apparently the Assyrians conquered Hazael's capital and brought these ivories to Hadatu as the spoils of war."
     - Elie Borowski, "Cherubim: God's Throne?" in Biblical Archaeology Review, July/August, 1995

See Ezekiel's Visions of the Throne-Chariot for a description of the creatures. Cornwell identifies the lion with the constellation Leo, the Ox with Taurus, the man with Aquarius (the water-bearer) and the eagle with Scorpio. These constellations are located at opposite quarters of the zodiac. Lee Perry identifies the creatures with the four Guardian Stars.

The four beasts are also similar to the karibu carved on the gates of Nebuchadrezzar's palace in Babylon.

Origins in the Sphinx
"Originally, the human-headed sphinx represented the Egyptian pharaoh, as in the famous Giza sphinx from the reign of Khephren (2520-2494 B.C.E.). Similar composite creatures, but winged and feminine, appear in wall-paintings at the palace of Zimri-lim at Mari (18th-century B.C.E.) and in ivory carvings from Acemhuyuk in Anatolia from the 19th or 18th century B.C.E. Toward the end of the second millennium, a wingless female sphinx appears in Egypt beside the male pharaoh sphinx-for example, Queen Tiy, consort of Amenhotep III (1391-1354 B.C.E.) is depicted in this way on a carnelian gem. Perhaps, as a result of cultural contacts with Western Asia, the sphinx was returned to its Egyptian homeland in female form.
"In Egypt, both male and female sphinxes symbolized royalty. Elsewhere the composite figures were protective beings, often symmetrically flanking a figure or object that was to be guarded. In the 18th-century B.C.E. wall-painting from Zimri-lim's palace at Mari, mentioned above, winged sphinxes, together with other fantastic animals, flank the goddess Ishtar and the king. This artistic convention, portraying two winged sphinxes in a heraldic composition, became popular all over the Near East, from Anatolia to ancient Israel. Examples may be seen in the female sphinxes flanking the gate at Alaca Huyuk in Anatolia, as well as in the creatures decorating the tenth-century B.C.E. cult stands from Taanach.* Winged creatures flanking a throne have been found on a 13th-century ivory from Megiddo, as well as on the sarcophagus of Ahiram from Lebanon, dating to the end of the second millennium B.C.E."
     - Tallay Ornan, "Symbols of Royalty and Divinity" in Biblical Archaeology Review, July/August, 1995

Clement of Alexandria

"The indications are that Christianity was well established in middle Egypt by A.D. 150 and that Alexandria was its port of entry and supporting base."
     - "Alexandrian Theology"

Titus Flavius Clemens, (b. 150 CE, Athens, d. between 211 and 215) was a "missionary theologian to the Hellenistic (Greek cultural) world, and second known leader and teacher of the catechetical school of Alexandria. The most important of his surviving works is a trilogy comprising the Protreptikos ('Exhortation'), the Paidagogos ('The Instructor'), and the Stromateis ('Miscellanies'")."
"According to Epiphanius, a 4th-century bishop, the parents of Titus Flavius Clemens were Athenian pagans. There is little significant information about his early life. As a student he travelled to various centres of learning in Italy and in the eastern Mediterranean area. Converted to Christianity by his last teacher, Pantaenus--reputedly a former Stoic philosopher and the first recorded president of the Christian catechetical school at Alexandria--Clement succeeded his mentor as head of the school in about 180."
     - Encyclopedia Britannica

"Clement of Alexandria became head of the Catechetical School about 190. A philosopher throughout his life, Clement saw Greek philosophy as a preparation for Christ, even as a witness to divine truth. Plato was a cherished guide. Sin is grounded in man's free will. Enlightement by the Logos brings man to knowledge. Knowledge results in right decisions. These draw a man toward God until he is assimilated to God (Stromata iv. 23). The Christian lives by love, free from passion. His life is a constant prayer. Clement set forth its pattern in minute detail in the Paedagogos. He took an optimistic view of the future of all men, but knowledge would be rewarded in the world to come. An allegorical exgesis of Scripture supported these views."
     - "Alexandrian Theology"

"During the next two decades [c. 180-200] Clement was the intellectual leader of the Alexandrian Christian community: he wrote several ethical and theological works and biblical commentaries; he combatted heretical Gnostics (religious dualists who believed in salvation through esoteric knowledge that revealed to men their spiritual origins, identities, and destinies); he engaged in polemics with Christians who were suspicious of an intellectualized Christianity; and he educated persons who later became theological and ecclesiastical leaders (e.g., Alexander, bishop of Jerusalem)."
     - Encyclopedia Britannica

Exagoge

"Ezekiel the Tragedian's Exagoge is one of the Old Testament Pseudepigrapha that survive only in quotation fragments. These quotation fragments are usually preserved in the work of others. The Exagoge is preserved in the Preparation For The Gospel by Eusebius....The conclusion I came to in this study was that the Exagoge was a Jewish work from between the 3rd and 1st centuries BC."
     - James R. Davila, "Hekhalot Literature and Shamanism"

Fourth Book of Ezra

The apocryphal 2 Esdras received its name "because of the opening verse: 'The second book of the prophet Ezra. . . .' The book is an apocalypse consisting largely of seven revelations (3:1-5:20; 5:21-6:34; 6:35-9:25; 9:38-10:59; 11:1-12:51; 13:1-58; 14:1-48) which are primarily concerned with moral themes. Apparently, at least three authors are responsible for 2 Esdras. The original author was probably a first-century Palestinian Jew who, writing in Aramaic or Hebrew, produced chaps. 3-14 (the original 4 Ezra). It was subsequently translated into Greek. A second-century Christian added a Greek introduction (chaps. 1-2). Finally, a third-century Christian added the last two chapters (15-16) in Greek....The purpose of the original author was to show that God is just, despite the evil of the Rome of his day and the calamities that had befallen Jerusalem..."
     - Craig A. Evans, Noncanonical Writings and New Testament Interpretation, (1992) pp. 10-11

"And now, O Lord, why hast thou given over the one to the many, and dishonored the one root beyond the others, and scattered thine only one among the many? And those who opposed thy promises have trodden down those who believed thy covenants. If thou dost really hate thy people, they should be punished at thy own hands."
     - 4 Ezra 5:28-30

"...The Apocalypse of Ezra (4 Ezra = 2 Esdras), which seems to have been compiled around the end of the first Christian century by a Jew who was somewhat disillusioned by the harshness with which the Lord had allowed Israel to be treated in the recent past -- especially the Fall of Jerusalem in 70 CE. The book probably was written in Semitic, and early translated into Greek, and from Greek into a variety of languages. The Semitic original has perished, along with the Greek translation (except for a few lines from 15.57-59, which in any event originally was not part of 4 Ezra...), so that present editions rest primarily on the ancient Latin version. In its present Latin form, 4 Ezra contains what is usually called a Christian framework (chs 1-2 = '5 Ezra' and 15-16 = "6 Ezra") between which the Apocalypse proper is sandwiched."
     - Robert A. Kraft, "Was there a 'Messiah-Joshua Tradition at the Turn of the Era?"

"4 Ezra...contains seven visions that God gave to Ezra the scribe/prophet."
     - Craig A. Evans, Noncanonical Writings and New Testament Interpretation, (1992) p. 25

The Jewish author writes about events leading up to the Last Judgment.

"For behold, the time will come, when the signs which I have foretold to you will come to pass, that the city which now is not seen shall appear, and the land which now is hidden shall be disclosed. And every one who has been delivered from the evils that I have foretold shall see my wonders. For my son the Messiah shall be revealed with those who are with him, and those who remain shall rejoice four hundred years. And after these years my son the Messiah shall die, and all who draw human breath. And the world shall be turned back to primeval silence for seven days, as it was at the first beginnings; so that no one shall be left."
     - 4 Ezra 7:26-30

Jubilee

"The biblical Jubilee year was the fiftieth year, the year following the succession of seven sabbatical years. Whereas a sabbatical year was one in which the land must lie fallow and rest (analogous to the Sabbath at the end of the week), in the jubilee year all land that had been alienated form its original owners was supposed to return to them. All Hebrew slaves were to be set free. The jubilee year began on the Day of Atonement and was signaled by the blowing of trumpets throughout the land and the proclamation of universal liberty."
     - Michael Wise, Martin Abegg, Jr., and Edward Cook, The Dead Sea Scrolls: A New Translation (1996) p. 455


Melchizedek

In the Old Testament
The priest who preceeded the Levite high priests at the Temple was not an Israelite:

"But he who first built it was a potent man among the Canaanites, and is in our own tongue called [Melchisedek], the Righteous King, for such he really was; on which account he was [there] the first priest of God, and first built a temple [there], and called the city Jerusalem, which was formerly called Salem."
     - Flavius Josephus, War of the Jews, Bk VI, Ch X, Sn 1

According to Genesis 14:17-20, Abraham/Abram met Melchizedik after a victorious battle against five mighty kings who had conquered southern Canaan.

"Then Melchizedek king of Salem [Jerusalem] brought out bread and wine. He was priest of God Most High, and he blessed Abram, saying, 'Blessed be Abram by God Most High, Creator [or 'Possessor'] of heaven and earth.'"
     - Genesis 14:18-19

After being blessed, Abram presented the priest-king with a tithe of all his battle booty.

"…Melchizedek is king of what Salem (or Shalom) means in Hebrew: he's king of peace in the sense of integration, wholeness. He's the 'royal man,' one who's conquered and unified his upper and lower natures, becoming perfect. Such men are called kings. He's also the only high priest in the Old Testament whom no one seems to have ordained."
     - Paul William Roberts, Journey of the Magi (1995) p. 273

"This non-Israelite priest-king appears in two places in the Hebrew Bible: Genesis 14:18-20 and Psalm 110:4. My own reading of the texts is that Genesis is drawing on traditional material from the Judean royal cult (or perhaps even from pre-Israelite traditions) to tie the more recently introduced figure Abram to Jerusalem (Salem) and its temple cult. Psalm 110 seems to indicate that there was a priesthood of Melchizedek tied to the Davidic king in the temple cult. I....think that he was a tutelary [guardian] deity of the Davidic house along the lines of ancestral deification in West Semitic royal cults."
     - James Davila, "Melchizedek as a Divine Mediator"

"The LORD says to my Lord: 'Sit at my right hand until I make your enemies a footstool for your feet.' The LORD will extend your mighty scepter from Zion; you will rule in the midst of your enemies. Your troops will be willing on your day of battle. Arrayed in holy majesty, from the womb of the dawn you will receive the dew of your youth [or your young men will come to you like the dew].
"The LORD has sworn and will not change his mind: ' You are a priest forever, in the order of Melchizedek.' The Lord is at your right hand; he will crush kings on the day of his wrath. He will judge the nations, heaping up the dead and crushing the rulers of the whole earth. He will drink from a brook beside the way [or The One who grants succession will set him in authority]; therefore he will lift up his head."
     - Psalm 110 of David

"Here there are three parties: David, the Lord, and David's Lord. David is the speaker, and he refers to the one that the Lord is speaking to as 'my Lord.' Certainly David is not equating 'my Lord' with himself. This may be paraphrased as: David says, 'The Lord said to my personal Messiah ... .' The Midrash [on Psalm 18:36] is correct in recognizing the Messianic Character of the psalm."
     - Rachmiel Frydland, "What The Rabbis Know About The Messiah"

Since Messiah is to be of the order of Melchizedek, then He, too, is to be Priest and King.

A God-like Being
"Every Jew believed that Elijah was to come back to earth. It was written in scripture (Mal 3:23-24); and, if he was to return, this meant that he, though a mortal, was not dead. All Jews also believed that Enoch was not dead (Gen 5:24). The so-called Enochic traditions give evidence that many thought Enoch existed somewhere in the cosmos and performed special cosmic functions. Recent discoveries near Qumran have brought another heavenly figure to light: Melchizedek, who was considered an elohim (literally, 'a god'). The Son of Man was even said in the Similitudes to have been created before time (lEn 48:3)."
     - Paolo Sacchi, "Recovering Jesus' Formative Background" in Jesus and the Dead Sea Scrolls (James H. Charlesworth, Ed. - 1992), p. 131

"God presides in the great assembly; he gives judgment among the 'gods' [Elohim]..."
     - Psalm 82 A psalm of Asaph

For the author of scroll 11Q13, the Melchizedek Text of Cave 11, "Melchizedek is an enormously exalted divine being, to whom are applied names that are generally reserved for God alone, the Hebrew names el and elohim. In the author's citation of Isaiah 61:2, which speaks of 'the year of the Lord's favor,' 'Melchizedek' is substituted even for the most holy name of Israel's God, Yahweh. Yet more remarkably, Melchizedek is said to atone for the sins of the righteous and to execute judgment upon the wicked - actions usually associated with God himself. By the power of Melchizedek, dominion on earth shall pass from Satan...to the righteous Sons of Light."
     - Michael Wise, Martin Abegg, Jr., and Edward Cook, The Dead Sea Scrolls: A New Translation (1996) p. 455

"[He shall pro]claim this decree in the fir[s] [wee]k of the jubilee period that foll[ows nine j]ubilee periods. Then the 'D[ay of Atone]ment' shall follow af[ter] the [te]nth [ju]bilee period, when he shall atone for all the Sons of [Light] and the peopl]e who are pre]destined to Mel[chi]zedek. [...] upo[n the]m [...] For this is the time decreed for 'the year of Melchiz[edik]'s favor' (Isa. 61:2, modified), [and] by his might he w[i]ll judge God's holy ones and so establish a righteous ki[n]gdom, as it is written about him in the Songs of David, 'A godlike being has taken his place in the council of God; in the midst of the divine beings he holds judgment' (Ps. 82:1. Scripture also s[ays] about him, 'Over [it] take your seat in the highest heaven; A divine being will judge the peoples' (Ps. 7:7-8)."
     - 11Q13 2:7-11

As the Angel Michael
According to the so-called Melchizedek text of Cave 11, "Melchizedek is a heavenly spirit responsible for the judgment of the angels, apparently serving a role similar to that of the archangel Michael. It is he who exacts vengeance for the people of God, battling against Satan and the spirits under his command."
     - Norman Golb, Who Wrote the Dead Sea Scrolls?, (1995) p. 380

"And Melchizedek will avenge the vengeance of the judgments of E[l ...from the hand of Be]lial and from the hand of all..."
     - 11QMelchizedek (2nd c. B.C.E.)

Where Melchizedek appears in the Dead Sea Scrolls, in the document called Melchizedek (11QMelch), he is identified with the 'Elohim' of Psalm 82:1, thus giving us yet another variation on the theme of an angel identified with a divine name.' As the earlier researchers have seen, typically, the name of the angel varies from tradition to tradition. Thus, Michael is God's 'mediator' and general archistrategos, 2En 33:10; TDan 6:1-5; TAbr 1:4; cf. LAE 14:1-2). Eremiel appears in the Apocalypse of Zephaniah (6:1-15), in which he is mistaken for God. In the Ascension of Isaiah 7:2-4, an angel appears whose name cannot be given. And Melchizedek is the favored angelic name in 11QMelch."
     - Alan F. Segal, "The Risen Christ and the Angelic Mediator Figures in Light of Qumran" in Jesus and the Dead Sea Scrolls (James H. Charlesworth, Ed. - 1992), p. 304

Like the Son of God
"...In the Epistle to the Hebrews, chapter seven is entirely devoted to employing Melchizedek (whose name means 'my Lord is justice') in an attack on Jewish priesthood and the Law. A prophetic figure of Christ, Melchizedek has 'no father, mother, or ancestry' according to this epistle. Therefore he's outside time, like a Son of God, exercising an eternal priesthood, one thus superior to that of the Jewish priests. Not only are the latter mortal, but in the person of their ancestor Abraham they gave tithes to Melchizedek and received his blessing. Like Melchizedek, Jesus is not of priestly descent but is described by the Pauline philosophy as 'a priest of the order of Melchizedek' (Hebrews 7:11-19)."
     - Paul William Roberts, Journey of the Magi (1995) p. 273

The author of Hebrews "says...that Melchizedek was a priest of a lineage superior to that of the Levitical priests, since even Abraham paid him homage (7.1-6). Furthermore, Melchizedek continues to serve as a priest forever, in some sense as if he were the Son of God himself (7.3)."
     - Norman Golb, Who Wrote the Dead Sea Scrolls?, (1995) p. 380

"This Melchizedek was king of Salem and priest of God Most High. He met Abraham returning from the defeat of the kings and blessed him, and Abraham gave him a tenth of everything. First, his name means 'king of righteousness'; then also, 'king of Salem' means 'king of peace.' Without father or mother, without genealogy, without beginning of days or end of life, like the Son of God he remains a priest forever."
     - Hebrews 7:1-3

In the Melchizedek text of Cave 11, the "congregation of the sons of righteousness" "heed the message of a second figure described in this writing as 'the messenger.' The messenger, also designated 'Anointed of the spirit' (Hebrew messiah), is conceived of as coming with a message from God, a message explicating the course of history (that is, a declaration of when the End shall come) and teaching about God's truths. This figure dies, an event that may correspond somehow with the text's references to 'jubilee periods'."
     - Michael Wise, Martin Abegg, Jr., and Edward Cook, The Dead Sea Scrolls: A New Translation (1996) p. 455

"This vi[sitation] is the Day of [salvation] that He has decreed [through Isai]ah the prophet [concerning all the captive,] inasmuch as Scripture sa[ys, 'How] beautiful upon the mountains are the fee[t of] the messeng[er] who [an]nounces peace, who brings [good] news, [who announces salvat]ion, who [sa]ys to Zion, "Your [di]vine being [reigns"' (Isa. 52:7).] This scripture's interpretation: 'the mounta[ins' are the] prophet[s], they w[ho were sent to proclaim God's truth and to] proph[esy] to all I[srael]. 'The messenger' is the [An]ointed of the spir[it], of whom Dan[iel] spoke, ['after the sixty-two weeks, an Anointed one shall be cut off' Dan. 9:26). The 'messenger who brings] good news, who announ[ces salvation'] is the one of whom it is wri[tt]en, ['to proclaim the year of the Lord's favor, the day of vengeance of our God;] to comfo[rt all who mourn]' Isa. 61:2)."
     - 11Q13 2:15-20

"How beautiful on the mountains are the feet of those who bring good news, who proclaim peace, who bring good tidings, who proclaim salvation, who say to Zion, "Your God reigns!""
     - Isaiah 52:7

['Zi]ion' is [the congregation of all the sons of righteousness, who] uphold the convenant and turn from walking [ing the way] of the people. 'Your di[vi]ne being is [Melchizedek, who will del]iv[er them from the po]wer of Belial."
     - 11Q13 2:23b-25

Incarnated as Jesus Christ
In the Melchizedek Tractate (NHC IX, 1) "from the Gnostic library discovered in Nag Hammadi, Egypt, is found in a single, exceedingly fragmentary Coptic MS of the fourth century C.E. Birger Pearson hazards a guess that the work was composed in the late second or early third century C.E, probably in Egypt, and it seems to have been written originally in Greek. In any case it must be later than the rise of Christianity. The contents of the work can be roughly summarized as follows: an angelic messenger brought a revelation to the high priest Melchizedek (known from Genesis 14), which described, inter alia, the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. This address concluded with instructions on to whom to reveal the message. Melchizedek arose with joy and carried out a number of rituals and invocations to Gnostic divinities. Then more heavenly messengers granted him another revelation that appears to indicate that Melchizedek himself will be incarnated as Jesus Christ (p. 25 of the codex). He will also defeat his enemies, the archons, in battle. After admonishing him not to reveal this knowledge without permission, the messengers ascended into the heavens."
     - James Davila, "Melchizedek as a Divine Mediator"

"greeted [me . . .]
They said to me, "Be [strong, O Melchizedek],
great [High-priest]
of God [Most High, for the archons],
who [are] your [enemies],
made war; you have [prevailed over them, and]
they did not prevail over you, [and you]
endured and [you]
destroyed your enemies [. . .]
of their [. . .]
will rest, in any [. . .]
which is living (and) holy [. . .]
those that] exalted themselves against him in [. . .]
flesh
"
     - Melchizedek Tractate (NHC IX, 1)

"Elsewhere (18.5-6), Jesus Christ, and thus apparently Melchizedek, is given the title 'Commander-in-chief ( arxistrategoV) [of the] All.' The Greek term arxistrategoV is a common title of the archangel Michael. Christ is also called 'glorious one' (but the reading is unclear) and the high angels assisting him are 'chief commanders ( arxistrategoV) of the luminaries ( fwsqer)' (6.2-3). There is a reference to an 'angel of light' in a broken context in 15.1 and the high angels are called 'commander' ( strategoV), 'luminary' ( fwsqer), and 'man-of-light' in 17.11-14 or commander in chief ( arxistrategoV) in 17.18-19. These terms recall Michael, the angel of light or prince of light at Qumran, who leads the heavenly armies against the forces of Belial."
     - James Davila, "Melchizedek as a Divine Mediator"

Michael's role is described in the account of the Elohim in the Book of Enoch, which was part of the corpus of literature found near Qumran. The Epistle to the Hebrews compares the high priesthood of Jesus to that of Melchizedek.

Scribes

The scribes were the "school teacher-lawyer-notary class of the Galilean towns."
     - Morton Smith, Jesus the Magician: Charlatan or Son of God? (1978) p. 56

In the gospels, the apologetic "material is intended to counter the polemic begun and carried on by the scribes, taken up by the high priest, and at two later periods, first from about A.D. 30 to 44 and again from about 70 to 100, vigorously pushed by the Pharisees. The addition of references to the Pharisees in stories and sayings that originally lacked them is a good indication that the original forms of such stories and sayings antedated the rise of Pharisaic influence after 70. Hence we may reasonably suppose that the outsiders' picture of Jesus discernible in the gospels is mainly that of the scribes and high priests of Jerusalem, but carries on considerable elements derived from the scribes of Galilee and from Jesus' lifetime."
     - Morton Smith, Jesus the Magician: Charlatan or Son of God? (1978) p. 57

Synagogue

"'Synagogue' is not Hebrew at all; it is Greek meaning 'bringing together' and it was originally a place for Jews to meet and organize their community needs in order to uphold the various laws, particularly their food laws."'
     - Christopher Knight & Robert Lomas, The Hiram Key: Pharaohs, Freemasons and the Discovery of the Secret Scrolls of Jesus

"During the period of the Second Temple (520 B.C.E. - 70 C.E.), the term synagogue did not refer primarily to a building but to an assembly. In the villages and towns of ancient Palestine, local affairs were governed by local people. The town or village assembly consisted of the townspeople who attended to a variety of matters - political, judicial, economic, as well as religious (there was no dividing line between religion and the state)."
"In most villages and towns of first-century Palestine, the assembly probably gathered in the town square or at the city gate. There were also generic assembly halls for such gatherings."
     - Robert W. Funk and The Jesus Seminar, The Acts of Jesus: What Did Jesus Really Do? (1998) p. 169

"None of the pre-70 buildings in Palestine that have been studied by archaeologists show any iconography or other indications that they are anything more than a place to meet."
     - Paul V. M. Flesher (Orion)

Scholars believed that during the second temple period, the faithful met in homes, not in a specific building used exclusively for worship. However, a pre-70 building has been identified as a synagogue.

"The oldest synagogue yet uncovered, a structure dating to about 75-50 BCE, has been excavated near Jericho.
"Unearthed by archeologist Ehud Netzer of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem in the Hasmonean winter palace complex near the banks of Wadi Kelt, the synagogue emerges onto the Jericho plain. It predates by more than 30 years the oldest previously known synagogue, at Gamla in the Golan Heights.
"Netzer,...found the synagogue beneath the ruins of a palace built by King Herod late in the first century BCE. The synagogue itself had been destroyed by an earthquake in 31 BCE, along with the rest of the Hasmonean complex."
"The Jericho structure, measuring 17x11 meters, is similar to the one on Gamla, said Netzer. The room is lined by colonnades on all four sides. The pillars were spaced along a base some 40-50 centimeters high which lined the entire room and served also as a bench on which the congregation sat.
"In one corner, a niche was cut into the wall. Netzer believes it may have served to store Torah scrolls.
"The synagogue was part of a complex that included a small courtyard, a ritual bath (mikve), and several small rooms. One of these rooms contained a large U-shaped bench which was evidently used for ceremonial meals. "
     - Abraham Rabinovich, The Jerusalem Post, March 30, 1998

In the first century C.E., "the typical Sabbath service in the synagogue consisted of lections read from the law, the Former Prophets, and the Latter Prophets....There might be also be a recitation from the Targum by memory and a sermon delivered by; the scribe expounding on the lections. These readings and preachings were interspersed with prayers and psalms to complete the worship experience."
     - John Shelby Spong, Liberating the Gospels, p. 105

"In Jesus' day, the activities that took place in assembly halls were mostly social and educational. The 'synagogue' was primarily a place of study where scripture (Torah and the Prophets) was read aloud and commented on."
     - Robert W. Funk and The Jesus Seminar, The Acts of Jesus: What Did Jesus Really Do? (1998) p. 169
Synagogue at Capernaum
Ruins of 3-4th c. Synagogue, Capernaum
Black basalt foundation dates to 1st c.

"'At some point, however, the synagogue turned from a meeting house into a temple, a place at which one could actually worship Yahweh."
     - Christopher Knight & Robert Lomas, The Hiram Key: Pharaohs, Freemasons and the Discovery of the Secret Scrolls of Jesus

This transition occurred in the decades following the destruction of the Temple in 70 C.E.

"After the destruction of the temple, synagogue buildings were erected and those buildings became centers of public worship and study. The synagogue that a friendly Roman officer built for Jewish elders (Luke 7:5) reflects post-70 conditions. Luke's picture of Corninth with a house-church next door to a synagogue building (Acts 18:7) also fits the later archaeological evidence.)"
"...The letters of Paul, make no mention of synagogues."
     - Robert W. Funk and The Jesus Seminar, The Acts of Jesus: What Did Jesus Really Do? (1998) p. 169

The Sibylline Oracles

Sibylline Oracles were "a collection of oracular prophecies in which Jewish or Christian doctrines were allegedly confirmed by a sibyl (legendary Greek prophetess); the prophecies were actually the work of certain Jewish and Christian writers from about 150 BC to about AD 180...In the Oracles the sibyl proved her reliability by first 'predicting' events that had actually recently occurred; she then predicted future events and set forth doctrines peculiar to Hellenistic Judaism or Christianity. The Jewish apologist Josephus and certain Christian apologists thought the works were the genuine prophecy of the sibyls and were greatly impressed by the way in which their doctrines were confirmed by external testimony. Both Theophilus of Antioch and Clement of Alexandria, 2nd-century Christian theologians, referred to the sibyl as a prophetess apparently no less inspired than the Old Testament prophets."
     - Encyclopaedia Britannica

"Scholars are unsure if there ever really was a 'Sibyl' who inaugurated this tradition. Collections of 'Sibylline' oracles appeared in a variety of centers in the ancient world. These collections enjoyed considerable prestige in the Roman Empire and allowed Jews and Christians to communicate their religious views....The collection...now makes up part of the Pseudepigrapha."
     - Craig A. Evans, Noncanonical Writings and New Testament Interpretation, (1992) p. 24

The Third Sibylline Oracle, "written ca. the middle of the 2d century BC in Egypt...tells how God sends a savior king who puts an end to all war and grants deliverance to the Jews. The reference is to some Hellenistic Egyptian ruler, either Ptolemy VI Philometor or his successor. The concluding section of the oracle prophesies a kingdom that God will raise up. The hopes of Isaiah are echoed as the Jerusalem temple becomes the goal of pilgrimage for all the nations, the conditions of paradise return, and universal peace prevails....All this is done by God, who is referred to throughout the oracle as 'the great King'. Additions were made to the Third Oracle in the 1st century BC. They prophesy the coming of a 'holy prince' who will rule over a universal kingdom, inaugurated by the fiery judgment of 'the great king, immortal God.' Again all this takes place on Earth."
     - John P. Meier, A Marginal Jew - Rethinking the Historical Jesus, Vol. 2.

"The Egyptian Sibylline tradition is remarkable for its lack of the otherworldly dimension so characteristic of the apocalyptic literature. There is no talk of angels and no expectation of resurrection."
     - John J. Collins, "The Kingdom of God in the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha"

"In the Byzantine period 12 of the compositions were collected in a single manuscript containing 14 books (of which numbers 9 and 10 are lost). An incomplete text of this collection was first published in 1545."
     - Encyclopaedia Britannica

Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs

"All these are the twelve tribes of Israel, and this is what their father said to them when he blessed them, giving each the blessing appropriate to him."
     - Genesis 49:28

"The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs were written between 109 and 106 B.C.E. by a Pharisee who greatly admired John Hyrcanus at the zenith of the Maccabean (or Hasmonean) dynasty. The conviction was that Hyrcanus and his Levite family constituted the messianic line. Later revisions condemn the apostate Hasmonean line and expect Messiah to come from the tribe of Judah. The Testaments are inspired by Jacob's testament in Genesis 49 and typically follow this form:
     (1) Introduction in which scene is set;
     (2) narrative from patriarch's life;
     (3) ethical exhortation;
     (4) prediction of future;
     (5) second exhortation; and
     (6) patriarch's burial.
Major theological themes would include:
     (1) forgiveness and grace, freely given to those of contrite spirit;
     (2) exhortation to love God and neighbor (T. Dan 5:3; Mark 12:30-31);
     (3) ethical teachings that frequently parallel the NT;
     (4) universalism, even Gentiles can be saved through Israel (T Levi 14:4; T Benj. 9:2);
     (5) Messiah (alternating between Levi and Judah) is free from sin; he is righteous, establishes new priesthood, mediator for Gentiles;
     (6) resurrection; and
     (7) demonology and doctrines about Antichrist.
Although some scholars have argued for Aramaic (cf. CTLevi ar; IO-TLevi ar; 4QTjos ar-, 40TJud ar: 4QTLevi arO,b,c) or Hebrew (3QTjud?; 4QTjud?; 4QTNaph) as the original language of the Testaments, it is more likely that Greek, one of the languages in which the Testaments have survived, was the original."
     - Craig A. Evans, Noncanonical Writings and New Testament Interpretation, (1992) pp. 28-29

The reference to priestly and royal messiahs in Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs reinforces the conviction that it was a pharisaic work.